I was hesitant to try the Truffle, as an Asian woman with solid black hair, eyelashes, eyebrows, etc. The truffle is so pretty and looks so natural! To me, the black Plushy look like I am wearing light mascara vs the truffle, that look like I have perfect natural eyelashes. The Plushy are very sturdy and reusable but very thin with a super thin spine. I also receive the most longevity with the Plushy without anything extra, average 7-10 days.